German Mutual Insurance has merged with Highland Mutual Insurance Company
effective January 1, 2024.
German Mutual Customers: If you have an existing policy with German Mutual, it will remain in effect until the 2024 renewal date on that policy. Prior to the policy lapsing, an agent will need to meet with you and write a new policy using Highland Mutual Insurance Company’s forms, rates and coverages. This should occur at least 6 weeks prior to the renewal date to allow time to process the new policy and provide sufficient time for billing and notify any mortgage companies. Please make sure your current addresses and phone numbers are on file, so contact can be made with you as needed.
NOTE: As of February 12, 2024, Agent, Kevin Hollaway, will be writing for Highland Mutual and will be focusing on those policies previously with German Mutual Insurance Company as well as any new business in Cole County/Moniteau Coutny area. Kevin can be reached at email: HighlandMutual.KevinHollaway@gmail.com or cell phone #: 573-298-2299. Additionally, the office can always be contacted at email: info@highlandmutual.com or by phone at 573-796-3614.